Expert perspectives

We must study how the social media ban impacts youth mental health

The UK Government is banning social media for under 16s. Wellcome are seizing this a once-in-a-generation opportunity for researchers to study how the digital world impacts youth mental health and shape better policy. 

A teenage girl is laying on a messy bed with an open book on her chest. She is looking at the ceiling.
Credit:

Counter/Getty

Young woman day-dreaming with book on bed

Catherine Sebastian

8-minute read
8-minute read
Listen to this article
We must study how the social media ban impacts youth mental health
Elapsed time:00:00Total time:00:00

My eldest daughter has just turned 11. She's about to make the transition from primary to secondary school, with all that entails in terms of growing independence.  

Like most parents, we have agonised over when to give her a phone, what kind of phone to get her, and what parental controls to put in place. We want her to be safe when out and about, but also safe online. And yet it feels like an experiment, one where we won't know if the decisions we have made are the right ones for some time to come. 

It’s a very personal decision, but it’s taken place amid international political conversation. The UK will ban social media for under-16s in Spring 2027, with additional restrictions for 16 and 17 year olds being explored. Greece's prime minister announced a social media ban for under-15s. This follows Australia's decision to ban under-16s, with similar proposals in France, Spain, Indonesia and Malaysia. 

What we still don't know about social media and mental health  

Nearly half of all mental health problems emerge by the age of 18. In my role as Head of Evidence for Mental Health at Wellcome, we want to find new ways to intervene early in anxiety, depression and psychosis. The conversation on how social media and the digital world affect young people's mental health is vitally important. And yet there is so much that we still do not know. 

I’m a firm believer in evidence-based policymaking. But where public concern is so high, politicians will sometimes have to move ahead of a fully developed evidence base. Still, the reality is that we need stronger evidence on how social media – and its restriction – affects young people's mental health. 

Building the evidence base 

What we have now is an incredible opportunity to build that evidence base and understand how changes in social media use affect young people.  

Wellcome is supporting UK-based research teams to deliver robust evaluations of the ban's impact on mental health. Researchers are measuring young people’s baseline mental health before the changes are introduced, so they can evaluate their impact once in place. Young people are included in designing the studies to ensure the research best addresses the issues they face.

University of Oxford, led by Sarah Bauermeister

Using data from up to 40,000 pupils, the largest school-based cohort in the UK, this project examines how social media restrictions affect mental health and which groups benefit. Researchers are exploring changes in social connection, loneliness, sleep, online behaviour, bullying, self-harm and exposure to harmful content. They are also developing resources for schools and assessing the wider economic and policy implications.

Cardiff University, led by Stephan Collishaw and Kelly Morgan

This project builds on the School Health Research Network, a whole-nation survey reaching around 98% of Welsh secondary schools and over 100,000 young people. It evaluates the restrictions across Wales using new data collected before and after their introduction, and interviews with young people and parents. Researchers are examining changes in mental health, wellbeing and online behaviour, including how experiences vary between groups. The study also explores how families and schools influence implementation.

University of Oxford, led by Mina Fazel and Holly Bear

This project focuses on young people who are on the margins of digital policy, who may be particularly affected, including those who are neurodivergent, gender-diverse, care-experienced, migrants or outside mainstream education. Researchers are comparing UK mental health trends with countries without similar restrictions and follow young people’s experiences over time. The study examines how they adapt to, comply with or circumvent the policy, identifying both benefits and unintended harms.

University of Birmingham, led by Victoria Goodyear and Miranda Pallan

This project examines how the restrictions affect the mental health and everyday lives of young people aged 8 to 18 concentrating on the physical mechanisms that are hard to capture in self-report surveys. Researchers are studying changes in sleep, physical activity, relationships, school engagement and potentially addictive social media use. Interviews with young people and families, alongside school, population, digital data and data captured through wearables helps reveal why the policy may benefit some young people and not others.

King’s College London, led by Gemma Knowles and Haruka Goto

Using an existing study of more than 3,000 young people aged 11 to 14, this project assesses how the restrictions affect mental health, who is most affected and why with a particular focus on misogynistic content and online sexual harassment. Digital diaries, activity tracking and interviews explores these online experiences, as well as social support and peer influence. The research pays particular attention to inequalities and differences in young people’s experiences.

University of Edinburgh, led by Alex Kwong and Aja Murray

This project combines large-scale data from four ongoing UK longitudinal cohorts of 3,300 participants with an in-depth study of 750 participants. Smartphone-based research tracks children and young people aged 5 to 15 before and after the restrictions. It examines changes in depression, anxiety, wellbeing, sleep, physical activity, social connection and digital engagement. Researchers will also investigate whether effects differ for girls, neurodivergent young people and those with existing mental health difficulties.

Born in Bradford, led by Dan Lewer

Drawing on the Born in Bradford study, this project compares young people’s mental health and social media use before and after the restrictions. School surveys and smartphone-use tracking explores effects on wellbeing, sleep, physical activity, and online and offline behaviour. Researchers are also examining differences between groups, levels of compliance and what happens when young people regain access to social media at 16.

University of Manchester, led by Margarita Panayiotou

This study develops and tests a framework that combines an understanding of wider systems with people's lived experiences to assess the impact of the restrictions. It recognises that the effects of restrictions can extend across many connected areas of life, including development, social relationships, education, family life and digital environments. These effects therefore cannot be fully understood through a single model linking exposure to outcomes. The study aims not only to understand whether the restrictions are effective, who they affect and why, but also how their effects change over time. In doing so, it seeks to improve the methods used to evaluate complex public-health interventions in real-world settings.

London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, led by Mark Petticrew and Amrit Kaur Purba

The study tracks under-16s before and after the ban, comparing them with older young adults unaffected by the restrictions. It takes social media platform usage data from before the ban to link to further mental health outcomes, while data from national health records and studies helps assess wider effects. Researchers are examining changes in mental health, sleep, wellbeing, friendships and school engagement to understand previous exposure to harmful content. It looks at compliance, circumvention and whether harms decline or shift elsewhere during the ban, including impacts on LGBTQ+ and neurodivergent young people.

University College London, led by Francesca Solmi

Surveying around 12,000 young people aged 11 to 18 before and after the restrictions, this project assesses their impact on anxiety and depression. It pairs data from the study to data that is routinely collected through clinical and administrative records. Researchers are comparing experiences around the age-16 threshold and working with young people and parents to understand how the policy affects different groups. The findings will identify who benefits or experiences harm, explain why, and inform future decisions by policymakers and technology companies.

There are so many vital research questions. What is the most effective way to safeguard young people from online harms? Will restrictions improve mental health and, if so, what exactly is driving the improvement? Are young people abiding by the ban, or are they finding a way to circumvent restrictions? Can this new knowledge help us to design better interventions for youth mental health? Are there any risks to restricting social media?   

The ban will not have an equal impact on all young people. Factors like your hobbies, whether you live in a city or the countryside, your home life and whether you have access to spaces where you feel like you belong will all change your relationship with social media and your mental health.   

The UK Government has said it will introduce the social media ban by Spring 2027. We have a narrow window to collect baseline data from before this point, so we can best evaluate the impact of these policy changes on mental health while also examining other outcomes such as exposure to harmful content. We expect it to be some time before we fully understand the effects, so we are asking teams to follow up for at least a year. 

A global research challenge 

While our focus is on the UK in this instance, there is also an opportunity for international research. With young people tuning into the same platforms globally, there is enormous potential for collaboration, data sharing and cross-cultural comparisons. The field is likely to offer researchers plenty of scope for further investigation and collaboration. The EU's Horizon science programme launched a funding programme for researchers to develop interventions to prevent harms from digital technologies on young people. These interventions could counteract addictive design or reduce exposure to harmful content. The framing here is rightly wider than social media. As the use of AI technology – and AI chatbots specifically – advances at pace, there are important questions as to their impact on young people's mental health.

As the digital sphere continues to evolve, research is vital for informing future decision-making and identifying the most effective ways to safeguard youth mental health. The goal posts will be continuously shifting, but soon I, and millions of other parents, will be better equipped to support our young people entering the digital world. 

  • Catherine Sebastian

    Head of Evidence

    Wellcome

    Cat leads the Evidence team. Her role is to ensure we find and fund the research most likely to make a difference in preventing and treating mental health problems.

    Connect with Catherine: